Reincarnation and Phobias

Spontaneous ‘past life’ memories in children are often accompanied by phobias that correspond with remembered traumas, especially those that resulted in death.  This article summarizes research findings that provide evidence of such a link.

Introduction

In a 1990 study, Ian Stevenson defines phobias as ‘irrational fears the magnitude of which far exceeds the strength of the observable stimulus’.1  Childhood phobias are extremely common, he states, citing three surveys showing incidences of 90% between the ages of two and fourteen years, 58% between six and twelve and 22% between two and seven, respectively.2

In an earlier work, Stevenson writes that while many of these fears can be traced to a frightening event experienced by the child, or suggestions by a parent, or imitation of another person manifesting the phobia, for many, ‘none of these common explanations apply because an appropriately formative event or influence from surrounding persons cannot be discovered’.3  This tendency was noticed as long ago as in the 1890s, Stevenson notes, citing nineteenth-century psychologist G Stanley Hall, who suggested a remote origin for such inexplicable fears and referred to Plato’s notion of metempsychosis (reincarnation), without actually offering it as explanation.

In his own research, Stevenson quickly found that children who remembered past lives often showed phobias that corresponded to traumas that emerged in their statements, especially death. Other researchers also found such patterns in their analyses of investigated child cases.

Prevalence

Stevenson and colleagues found that of 387 subjects who recalled a previous life, 141 (36%) had suffered at least one related phobia.4  Cultural variations were found; among solved cases (cases in which the child’s previous incarnation has been identified with reasonable certainty), the lowest incidence was found in Indian cases (16%) and the highest in the Druze sect in Lebanon (51%).5

Phobias among children who remembered past lives, Stevenson found, ‘almost always’ correspond with the way in which their previous life ended, and mostly relate to violent deaths, occurring much more rarely after natural deaths.6  However, there are exceptions, as in the case of Parmod Sharma, whose previous incarnation had died of gastroenteritis after gorging on contaminated yogurt, and who himself was averse to yogurt.7

Stevenson found that, among 47 subjects who seemingly drowned in a previous incarnation, 30 (64%) exhibited a phobia of water.  A 1993 study showed that in 50 clinical cases of childhood phobia of water in the general population, in 28(56%) the parents knew of no traumatic experience or influence that could explain it; the fear arose at the moment of the child’s first contact with water.8  Such cases might be explained by past-life drownings, Stevenson suggested.

Similarly, among 30 individuals who had seemingly died of a snake bite in the previous incarnation, 13 (43%) exhibited a phobia of snakes.9 In addition, 10 (40%) had birthmarks that were related either to the wound or to attempts to treat it.10 

U Po Thwai of Myanmar recalled having been a snake-charmer in his previous life, which ended when a snake bit him; unable to get emergency aid he died the next day. He started his new life with a love for snakes; as a young child he would catch small snakes and play snake-charmer with them. However, between the ages of 16 and 18, he experienced hallucinations of snakes and his fascination changed to terror. This phobia lasted at least until middle age.11

Generalization, Transfer and Sensory Association

Stevenson cites previous studies to show that phobias often involve generalization or transfer (fear of stimuli that abstractly resemble the cause of the trauma), or sensory association (fear triggered by sensory inputs resembling the sensory inputs of the trauma).

Examples of Generalization or Transfer

As a young girl, Daw Aye Myint of Myanmar had a fear of all men of around 25, the age of the man who murdered her in her previous incarnation.12 

Maung Nyunt, also of Myanmar, died when he fell from a pony-cart he had been driving in his previous life. In his current life, he exhibited a fear of driving pony-carts, and of heights generally.13 

Ngozi Uduji, a Nigerian Igbo, was identified through a birth defect as the reincarnation of a cousin of her father who had been killed by bombing in the Biafran War. She feared airplanes, also the sight and sound of guns and of white men, possibly remembering white men who served as mercenary airplane pilots for the Nigerian Army.14

Examples of Sensory Association

Ma Myint Thein of Myanmar was born with fingers missing and deformed. In early childhood she stated that she had been murdered by men with swords and indicated the spot where it had happened.15 

Necati Çaylak of Turkey recalled the life of a man who had died in a car accident on a bridge. As a young child he cried upon first seeing the bridge, and appeared afraid to cross over it. The fear lasted until he was around ten years old.16

Early Expression

In some cases, Stevenson notes, phobias manifest before the child speaks of the past life, or is even able to speak at all.  As an infant, Shamlinie Prema of Sri Lanka manifested an extreme dislike of being bathed, struggling so hard that it took three people to hold her.  She also showed a fear of buses. When she could talk she began speaking of a past life, eventually identified as that of a girl who had drowned at the age of eleven, jumping out of the way of a bus into a rice paddy.17

Sujith Lakmal Jayaratne of Sri Lanka showed a fear of lorries (trucks) at eight months of age; the English loan-word ‘lorry’ was among the first words he uttered. When able to talk in sentences, he described having died after being run over by a lorry when he drunkenly stepped into the road. His many other statements relating to a past life identified it as that of an individual who had died in this way.18

Phobias in Cases Without Memories

In some researched cases, the origin of a phobia has been attributed to past life memories by the individual’s relatives rather than by the individual.  Derek Pitnov, a member of the Alaskan Tlingit, had a diamond-shaped birthmark which, according to local elderwomen, resembled the spear-wound that killed his great-great-grand-uncle Chak-nik-kooh.  From childhood, Pitnov exhibited a phobia of bladed weapons: he wouldn’t play with knives and intensely disliked bayonet drill.19

A past life was identified in the case of Maung Sein Nyunt of Myanmar through an announcing dream experienced by his mother, a birthmark similar to a blemish on the skin of the previous person, and a phobia: in the previous life he had drowned while swimming in a lake, and in his current life he showed a fear of water until his mid-teens.20

Multiple Phobias

Daw Tin Hla of Myanmar recalled the life of a man who had been brutally murdered with a sword, the first blows slashing off his fingers and the final one striking his neck.  As well as being born with missing fingers, the girl was afflicted with multiple related phobias.  Her fear of blood was so severe it made her physically ill, to the extent that she found herself unable to aid a friend with an injured hand.  She dreaded swords and large knives that could be used as weapons (although she was unafraid of kitchen knives).  She felt uneasy if anyone touched her on the neck.  In any group she refused to be at the rear, preferring to be in the middle and so protected by other people in case of attack.  These phobias persisted well into adulthood.21

Duration

Stevenson writes that childhood phobias relating to past deaths tend to be strongest while the children are most frequently speaking of their memories, usually between the ages of two and four years.  They tend to fade along with the memories themselves as the child gets older, but can sometimes persist. Stevenson cites the case of a young child who had a marked fear of the person who murdered his previous incarnation. Aged eleven, he still feared the murderer but couldn’t remember why; at thirteen, this was no longer the case, but he remembered that he had feared him earlier.

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder

Parapsychologist Erlendur Haraldsson conducted psychological studies of children who remembered past lives, investigating the argument that past-life memories indicate psychological disturbance.  In two studies in Sri Lanka22 23 and a third in Lebanon,24 using standard psychological checklists, he and his co-authors found that children who remembered past lives performed well socially, but compared to other children tended to be high-strung and tense, perfectionistic, anxious and nervous, argumentative, prone to angry outbursts, moody and somewhat obsessive. Where they were tested for dissociative tendencies, children who remembered past lives scored higher.

The researchers checked for conflicts and signs of neglect or abuse, which might explain these findings, but found nothing unusual. Haraldsson notes that past-life related phobias clearly contributed to these scores, as did apparent changes of personality as the children shifted back and forth between reliving the previous and the current life.25 Experts on post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) pointed out that such characteristics are common among people who have suffered identifiable traumas. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), a diagnosis of PTSD requires three criteria:

  • the patient was exposed to an event or situation ‘of exceptionally threatening or catastrophic nature’
  • persistent remembering and ‘reliving’ of the stressor in intrusive ‘flashbacks’, vivid memories
  • difficulty in falling or staying asleep; irritability or outbursts of anger; difficulty concentrating; hypervigilance; exaggerated startle response

Haraldsson noted similarities between his study findings and the WHO criteria. He also observed that children with past-life memories of violent death often do seem to remember them intrusively, even to the point of re-experiencing them. Accordingly, he postulates that at least some children with past-life memories suffer from PTSD. 

Further indications are provided by an American study by Jim Tucker and FD Nidiffer, in which two of fifteen participating children who remembered a previous life showed significant dissociative behaviour.26  Elsewhere, Tucker writes: ‘In the cases in which the previous person died an unnatural death, over 35% of the children show an intense fear of the mode of death, the kind of avoidant behaviour that is a part of the official DSM [Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders] criteria for PTSD’.27

In her book Children’s Past Lives, child reincarnation researcher Carol Bowman offers advice to parents whose children are troubled by phobias and other painful emotions arising from past lives.  She emphasizes that parents should be open-minded, non-judgmental and calm, and recommends gently eliciting the story, especially if it includes death, to learn what might be causing them. However, parents should not insist if the child becomes reluctant to speak, or probe too hard while the child is emotional.28

Bowman strongly advises allowing the release of emotions rather than discouraging it.29  She also cautions parents not to reject accounts of death as dangerous or morbid, or try to suppress them, but rather recommends helping the child stay with the memories and emotions while they are present, as potential healing opportunities.30

Karen Wehrstein

Literature

Bowman, C. (1997).  Children’s Past Lives: How Past Life Memories Affect Your Child. New York: Bantam Books.

Haraldsson E. (1995). Personality and Abilities of Children Claiming Previous-Life Memories. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 183(7), pp. 445-51.

Haraldsson, E., Fowler, P. & Periyannanpillai, V. (2000). Psychological Characteristics of Children Who Speak of a Previous Life: A Further Field Study in Sri Lanka. Transcultural Psychiatry, 37, pp. 525-44.

Haraldsson, E. (2003). Children Who Speak of Past-Life Experiences: Is There a Psychological Explanation? Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory Research and Practice. 76, 1, pp. 55-67.

Haraldsson, E. and J.G. Matlock (2016). I Saw a Light and Came Here: Children’s Experiences of Reincarnation.  Hove, UK: White Crow Books.

Stevenson, I. (1966, revised 1974).  Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation.  Charlottesville, Virginia, USA: University Press of Virginia.

Stevenson, I. (1977a). The Explanatory Value of the Idea of Reincarnation.  Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 164:5, pp 305-26.

Stevenson I. (1977b). Cases of the Reincarnation Type, Vol II: Ten Cases in Sri Lanka. Charlottesville, Virginia, USA: University Press of Virginia.

Stevenson, I. (1980).  Cases of the Reincarnation Type, Vol III: Twelve Cases in Lebanon and Turkey. Charlottesville, Virginia, USA: University Press of Virginia.

Stevenson, I. (1990). Phobias in Children who Claim to Remember Previous Lives. Journal of Scientific Exploration 4:2, pp. 243-254. Retrieved January 29, 2018 from

https://med.virginia.edu/perceptual-studies/wp-content/uploads/sites/267/2015/11/STE34Stevenson-1.pdf.

Stevenson, I. (1997a). Reincarnation and Biology: A Contribution to the Etiology of Birthmarks and Birth Defects, Vol. 1.  Westport, Connecticut, USA: Praeger.

Stevenson, I. (1997b). Reincarnation and Biology: A Contribution to the Etiology of Birthmarks and Birth Defects, Vol. 2.  Westport, Connecticut, USA: Praeger.

Stevenson, I. (2003). Children Who Remember Previous Lives: A Question of Reincarnation. Rev. ed. Jefferson, North Carolina, USA: McFarland.

Tucker, J.B. (2013). Return to Life: Extraordinary Cases of Children Who Remember Past Lives. New York: St. Martin’s Press.

Tucker, J. B., & Nidiffer, F. D. (2014). Psychological Evaluation of American Children Who Report Memories of Previous Lives. Journal of Scientific Exploration, 28, 583–594.

References

  • 1. Stevenson (1990), p. 243.
  • 2. Stevenson (1990), p. 243.
  • 3. Stevenson (1977a), p. 312.
  • 4. Cook et al (1983), Table 5, p. 126.
  • 5. Cook et al (1983), Table 5, p. 126.
  • 6. Stevenson (1990), p. 247.
  • 7. Full case study: Stevenson (1974), pp 109-27.
  • 8. Menzies, R. G., and Clarke, J. C. (1993). The Etiology of Childhood Water Phobia. Behavior Research and Therapy 31, pp. 499–501.
  • 9. Stevenson (2003), p. 183.
  • 10. Stevenson (1997a), p. 997.
  • 11. Stevenson (1997a). Full case study: pp. 681-3.
  • 12. Full case study: Stevenson (1997a), pp. 227-34.
  • 13. Full case study: Stevenson (1997a), pp. 606-9.
  • 14. Full case study: Stevenson (1997b), pp. 1330-35.
  • 15. Full case study: Stevenson (1997b), pp. 1200-1215.
  • 16. Full case study: Stevenson (1980), pp. 299-323.
  • 17. Full case study: Stevenson (1977b), pp. 15-42.
  • 18. Full case study: Stevenson (1977b), pp. 235-80.
  • 19. Full case study: Stevenson (1966/74), pp. 252-9.
  • 20. Full case study: Stevenson (1997b), pp. 705-8.
  • 21. Full case study: Stevenson (1997b), pp. 1215-22.
  • 22. Haraldsson (1995).
  • 23. Haraldsson et al. (2000).
  • 24. Haraldsson (2003).
  • 25. Haraldsson and Matlock (2016), pp. 116-7. Information in this section is drawn from this work except where otherwise noted.
  • 26. Tucker & Nidiffer (2014).
  • 27. Tucker (2013), p. 141.
  • 28. Bowman (1997), pp. 262-3.
  • 29. Bowman (1997), p. 270.
  • 30. Bowman (1997), p. 271-2.