William Bengston and Energy Healing

William Bengston (b. 1950) is an American sociology professor, author and practitioner of ‘energy healing’. Bengston’s writings contain numerous anecdotal descriptions of healings of cancer and other serious diseases, and also of successful laboratory experiments with mice.

Introduction

William Bengston was born in New York City in 1950 and received his PhD in sociology from Fordham University in New York in 1980.  Two of his specialties are research methodology and statistics.  After 39 years of ad hoc psychic research, he wrote The Energy Cure in 2010, an autobiography which also explores the nature of his work and his theories about it.  All details in this article are drawn from this book except where otherwise noted.

As a teenager, Bengston says he was ‘open-minded to psychic phenomena in principle, but intensely skeptical of those claiming to produce it’.1 He experienced a number of dreams around death that had proven ‘startlingly prophetic’, and this prompted him to start reading the literature of paranormal research. He was impressed by the results of laboratory ESP experiments conducted with strict protocols.

Bennett Mayrick

Aged 21, having gained his baccalaureate, he met an individual named Bennett Mayrick, who claimed to be psychic, having accidentally discovered a gift for psychometry only months earlier. Bengston was skeptical, but was persuaded when Mayrick gave him an accurate reading. The two became friends, and explored psychic phenomena together, Mayrick performing regular readings while Bengston was taking his masters in sociology.

Bengston was keen for Mayrick to submit to testing. Mayrick considered the exercise pointless, since it would convince no one who did not wish to be convinced. However, he agreed under protest to be tested by Karlis Osis, a parapsychologist at the American Society for Psychical Research in New York. While describing the contents of a sealed envelope, an EEG machine gave a readout that showed his brain producing beta and theta waves at the same time, which was thought at the time to result from a mechanical malfunction, but which Bengson later discovered was reported in relation to some adepts of yogic meditation. Mayrick also tested positively for psychokinesis on a random event generator.

Later that year, Mayrick discovered he was able to relieve pain in people to whom he was giving readings. Bengston was suffering chronic back pain at the time, and took the opportunity to test this by asking Mayrick to lay a hand on the spot.  In ten minutes, the pain was gone and did not return. 

Bengston set up an informal double-blind test of Mayrick’s diagnostic abilities at Deepdale Hospital in Little Neck, New York. Mayrick successfully described the ailments of all eight of the patients he was confronted with.

Mayrick went on to provide healing on a regular basis. Bengston observed closely and in due course, at Mayrick’s urging, began to practice healing himself. He attempted it first with minor ailments, experiencing the same phenomena as Mayrick described: a sense of energy running through his body, a growing warmth in his hand, and a sense of ‘hot spots’ on a patient’s body indicating areas that needed to be treated.  Bengston also researched psychic healing literature, learning about the experiments of Bernard Grad, Justa Smith and Dolores Krieger.

Laboratory Experiments with Mice

Bengson now attempted to get Mayrick to agree to have his healing ability tested in a laboratory, and arranged through David Krinsley, a friend and eminent geologist, to set up a controlled experiment at Queens College of the City University of New York. However, Mayrick would not be persuaded, forcing Bengston to take his place at the last minute. 

Bengston was successful in curing all five experimental mice, which had been injected with cancer cells that normally produced 100% fatality within 27 days (see details below).

Bengston and Krinsley then replicated the experiment, using as healers Krinsley, two graduate students who were highly skeptical, and Marvin Wasserman, head of the Queens University biology department, having been given the necessary training by Bengston. All seven experimental mice were cured, as were four of the control mice. 

The experiment was replicated again in a different lab with some change in the healer personnel.  The results of all replications were an 87.9% cure rate in 33 experimental mice. Bengston and Krinsley published a paper on the experiments in 2000.2 An experiment to similarly heal cancer in carrots, which do not have an immune system, failed, suggesting that energy healing’s efficacy was related to the immune system.

After concentrating on his sociology career for two decades, and psychically healing only family and friends, Bengston returned to experimentation in 2000, inspired by reactions to his and Krinsley’s publications. Going public increased his healing practice.  Further experiments with mice at the University of Connecticut’s Medical Center in 2002 were shut down despite promising initial results.

Resonant Bonding

With time to spare, Bengston formulated his theory of resonant bonding, which posits that living creatures share an energetic bond by which they can influence each other’s health.  This, he hypothesized, might be why control mice situated near the experimental mice and the healers tended also to become cancer-free.  He also hypothesized that resonant bonding might explain the placebo effect.  He and a doctor conducted further experiments with mice, including healing over a distance, and co-authored a paper published in 2007.3

Bengston had himself tested with functional magnetic resonance imaging, showing that his brain responded when he unwittingly held pictures of cancer-afflicted animals, or did healing on human patients.  Using electroencephalography, Bengston and his co-authors found that the healer’s brainwave frequency would match Schumann’s resonance—an electromagnetic wave that continually circles the planet—and the patient’s brainwaves would harmonize as well.4  Clinical experimentation with charging substances such as water and cotton with healing energy also had good results.

Patterns in Energy Healing

In his autobiography, Bengston notes certain patterns that he observed in his, Mayrick’s and others’ psychic healing of cancer and other diseases, in both experimental and clinical settings:

  • neither the healer nor the patient needed to believe in it for it to be successful
  • the most aggressive types of cancers were most responsive to treatment
  • healing did not work as well, if at all, after radiation or chemotherapy
  • some human patients genuinely did not want to recover from illnesses, and so would not return after initial positive results, or otherwise sabotage treatment
  • after an injury, the sooner the patient was treated, the faster and better the results were
  • the longer a patient had had a condition, the longer it took to cure
  • younger patients with generally good health were easier to treat than older patients with multiple conditions
  • sometimes an initial aggravation of symptoms would occur, prior to cure
  • mice cured in the experiments also became immune to the same type of cancer, as they would not grow tumours even if re-injected with the cancer cells
  • water and cotton given psychic-healing treatments became curative if applied or ingested
  • anyone, even skeptics, could acquire healing ability if they followed Bengston’s instructions and training
  • negative emotions could interfere with healers’ ability
  • cancer remission happened intermittently, in bursts alternating with plateaus

Academic Resistance

Mayrick predicted to Bengston in the 70s that there was no point in conducting scientific experiments on psychic healing since the medical and science communities would never accept the findings.  Bengston’s experience had confirmed this at least up to the time of writing of his autobiography in 2010. ‘I’m still hoping that Ben was wrong about that word “never”,’ he writes.5

Neither of the scientists in the biology field who aided him in conducting experiments – Marvin Wasserman and Carol Hayes, chair of the biology department on the Brooklyn campus of St. Joseph’s College in New York at the time – were willing to continue with psychic healing experimentation. Bengston speculated that this was because it was relevant to their specialism and their careers would be at greater risk than his or Krinsley’s, neither of whom were involved in biology or medicine.

Although experiments had been agreed to at the University of Connecticut, Bengston was distressed by the indifference and hostility he encountered, being refused proper facilities and ostracized by the department head. He subsequently learned that a higher authority in the university was resentful that his program had been approved.

Bengston expected to arouse debate when he spoke publicly about his healing experiments, but instead typically met only with silence. Scientists and doctors expressed fear of losing either reputations or licenses for being associated with psychic healing; in other cases, they rejected his evidence outright.

In an article entitled ‘The Boggle Effect’, Bengston speculated on why people dismiss experimental evidence even when they cannot find methodological flaws. He writes: ‘My experience is that there are many scientists who have an abiding interest in various anomalies, but have exercised their academic discretion so that their public research remains safely within established paradigms’.6  He laments that oncology and medical science generally show no signs of interest in his work.

Theoretical Speculation

In a chapter of his autobiography entitled ‘Touching the Source’, Bengston ruminates on his experience of psychic healing and how it might work.  He writes that he accesses ‘the Source’, a wellspring providing an ‘infinite supply’ of healing energy.  ‘My mind moves… into superconsciousness and a sense of higher intelligence, then past that into peace, and past that into Nothingness – a place of pure potential where all possibilities exist at the same time’.7 He speculates that healing involves accessing these parallel existences:

‘Perhaps there’s a place where you crushed your finger, and a place where you did not; there’s a place where the finger heals, and a place where it does not. These places are probably very close to each other, so if we act quickly before your thoughts have had a chance to harden around a negative reality, maybe we can make it back together to the noncrushed-finger time’. 

With slow-developing conditions such as some cancers, he proposes, the healer possibly moves the patient through a series of existences in which the cancer is successively diminished. ‘Perhaps this means moving forward in time or perhaps it means moving back’, Bengston writes, ‘because inside the Source present, past, and future are without distinction’.  Consciousness is not plural, he notes, so perhaps the healer’s and patient’s consciousness travel together.8

Future Research

Bengson acknowledges that his practical and experimental work leaves a number of questions unanswered, and these should be the focus of future research. They include:

  • how many treatments are necessary to produce remission?
  • with distance healing, how does the rate of remission vary with distance?
  • do multiple healers add to the positive effects?
  • can healing energy be detected and measured?
  • can a person or animal who has become immune to a disease, having been cured of it by energy healing, pass this immunity on to offspring?
  • can blood from an organism that has been remitted be used as a vaccine to treat others?

Experiment Details

Initial experiments are summarized as follows (from the abstract of  W. F. Bengston and D. Krinsley, 2000, The Effect of the “Laying On of Hands” on Transplanted Breast Cancer in Mice, Journal of Scientific Exploration 14/3, pp. 353–364):

We obtained five experimental mice with mammary adenocarcinoma (code: H2712; host strain: C3H/HeJ; strain of origin: C3H/HeHu), which had a predicted 100% fatality between 14 and 27 days subsequent to injection. Bengston treated these mice for 1 hour per day for 1 month. The tumors developed a “blackened area,” then they ulcerated, imploded, and closed, and the mice lived their normal life spans. Control mice sent to another city died within the predicted time frame. Three replications using skeptical volunteers (including D.K.) and laboratories at Queens College and St. Joseph’s College produced an overall cure rate of 87.9% in 33 experimental mice. An additional informal test by Krinsley at Arizona State resulted in the same patterns. Histological studies indicated viable cancer cells through all stages of remission. Reinjections of cancer into the mice in remission in Arizona and New York did not take, suggesting a stimulated immunological response to the treatment. Our tentative conclusions: Belief in laying on of hands is not necessary in order to produce the effect; there is a stimulated immune response to treatment, which is reproducible and predictable; and the mice retain an immunity to the same cancer after remission. Future work should involve testing on various diseases and conventional immunological studies of treatment effects on experimental animals.

Publications

Bengston’s publications related to psychic healing include:

Introduction: Remembrances of Bernard Grad, forthcoming in Bernard Grad, On the Road to Healing and Biogenesis. 2016. 9

Challenges for Preclinical Investigations of Human Biofield Modalties, Biofield Science and Healing: Toward a Transdisciplinary Approach, 2015 (with Gloria Gronowicz and Garret Yount)

Spirituality, Connection, and Healing with Intent: Some Reflections on Cancer Experiments on Laboratory Mice, in Lisa Miller (ed.), Oxford Handbook of Spirituality and Psychology. 2012. Oxford University Press.

The Boggle Effect, EdgeScience, no. 12, Oct-Dec, 2012.

Crossing Disciplinary Boundaries: Going Beyond even Meta-Analysis on Distant Intention, Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, vol 18(6), June 2012.

Some Implications of the Reported Effects of Johrei on the Viability and Proliferation of Cultured Cancer Cells In Vitro, Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 18 (3), March 2012

Consciousness and the Source of Reality, Journal of Scientific Exploration 25(4), Winter 2012, pp. 821-825.

Science and Hands-On Healing, Bridges Magazine, vol. 21(2), 2011.

Breakthrough: Clues to Healing with Intention. EdgeScience, no.2, January/March 2010, p. 5-9.

The Healing Connection: EEG Harmonics, Entrainment, and Schumann's Resonances. Journal of Scientific Exploration 24/4, Winter 2010, pp. 655-666. (with Luke Hendricks and Jay Gunkelman)

Anomalous DC Magnetic Field Activity during a Bioenergy Healing Experiment. Journal of Scientific Exploration 24/3, pp. 397-410, 2010. (with Margaret Moga)

Some Patterns of Acceptance of Anomalies. The Explorer 22/3, Spring 2009, p.7-9.

Can Healing Be Taught? Explore 4/3, pp. 197-200, May/June 2008. (with Don Murphy)

Resonance, Placebo Effects, and Type II Errors: Some Implications from Healing Research for Experimental Methods. Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 13/3, pp. 317-327, May 2007. (with Margaret Moga)

A Method Used to Train Skeptical Volunteers to Heal in an Experimental Setting, Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 13/3, pp. 329–331, 2007.

Methodological Difficulties Involving Control Groups in Healing Research. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine  10/2, April 2004.

Directions in Healing Research, Journal of Scientific Exploration 15/1, pp. 128-130, Spring 2001.

Scientific Disclosure, Journal of Scientific Exploration 15/1, Spring 2001.

Anomalies in Anomalous Research, Journal of Scientific Exploration 15/1, Spring 2001.

Some Implications of the Bengston/Krinsley Healing Experiments, Monterey Institute for the Study of Alternative Healing Arts 30-31, December 2000, pp. 353-364.

The Effect of the 'Laying On of Hands' on Transplanted Breast Cancer in Mice, Journal of Scientific Exploration, Fall 2000, 14/3, pp. 353-364 (with David Krinsley).

Website

Bengston’s own website at www.bengstonresearch.com10 provides information on psychic healing, his current and anticipated projects, articles, and more.  Pages include: Workshops, Book & CD, Research (Projects, Scientific Articles, Presentations), Interviews/Videos, Resources (Suggested Reading, Suggested Websites).

Karen Wehrstein

Sources

Bengston, W. (2012).  The Boggle Effect. EdgeScience 12, pp 3-5.  Retrieved September 26, 2017 from https://www.bengstonresearch.com/content_assets/docs/boggle_factor._edge_sciences.pdf

Bengston, W., with S. Fraser (2010).  The Energy Cure.  Boulder, Colorado, USA: Sounds True.

Bengston, W. and D. Krinsley (2000). The Effect of the 'Laying On of Hands' on Transplanted Breast Cancer in Mice, Journal of Scientific Exploration 14(3), pp 353-364.  Retrieved September 26, 2017 from https://www.bengstonresearch.com/content_assets/docs/JSE%20-%20The%20Effect%20of%20the%20Laying%20On%20of%20Hands%20on%20Transplanted%20Breast%20Cancer%20in%20Mice.pdf

Bengston, W. and M. Moga (2007). Resonance, Placebo Effects, and Type II Errors: Some Implications from Healing Research for Experimental Methods. Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 13(3), pp 317-327.  Retrieved September 26, 2017 from https://www.bengstonresearch.com/content_assets/docs/JACM%20-%20Resonance,%20Placebo%20Effects....pdf

Hendricks, L., W. Bengston and J. Gunkelman (2010). The Healing Connection: EEG Harmonics, Entrainment, and Schumann's Resonances. Journal of Scientific Exploration, 24:4, pp. 655-666. Retrieved September 26, 2017 from https://www.bengstonresearch.com/content_assets/docs/JSE_EEG_Hendricks_Bengston_Gunkelman.pdf

References